Wednesday, December 31, 2014

PAKISTAN VS INDIA: MFN TREARTMENT AND IMPLICATIONS

  • Asif Maqbool 
  • Muhammad Rasheed

Trade relations between India and Pakistan appear set to improve significantly with Pakistan to grant India Most Favored Nation (MFN) status. Trade between India and Pakistan is as old as the two countries are, but the volume of trade between them is very small relative to the size of their economies. However, this has not always been the case. After 1947, Pakistan’s exports and imports with India remained quite significant for several years, as high as 30 percent of exports and 10 percent of imports. The potential gains from easier trading relations are considerable for both countries. In 2009-10, official trade between the two stood at $2 billion. Studies suggest this volume could be much higher, absent formal and informal barriers. For instance, a recent SAARC report estimates trade potential to be $12 billion.
All WTO members are bound to grant MFN treatment to member countries with respect to trade in goods. India granted Pakistan MFN status in 1996, but Pakistan held back, citing strategic considerations. SAU has been using the granting of MFN as a tool to achieve various objectives with respect to various countries, such as China, Cuba, Iran, and Libya, for years.
Despite granting Pakistan MFN status, India continued to impose high tariffs on goods of interest to Pakistan—textiles and leather. Thus, merely according MFN status does not imply easier trade. So, does Pakistan’s offer matter? Yes, it does. It signals enthusiasm, goodwill, and a keenness to build peaceful and productive economic and political relations in the region.
The gains are likely to come from existing markets as well as new ones. The former includes informal (illegal) trade, conducted through cross border smuggling and personal baggage — and according to some estimates, worth $13 billion. It also includes trade to the tune of $3-3.5 billion conducted through third-parties, such as Dubai, since direct trade is difficult. The potential for new markets is tremendous. For instance, a Government College University study suggests expanding Pakistan’s light engineering sector. The same study suggests that India has a relative advantage in bicycle production, which it could export to Pakistan. Additionally, as FICCI secretary–general, Rajiv Kumar notes, if Indian goods are permitted to transit through Pakistan and access Central Asian markets, then traders in Haryana, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and North Rajasthan stand to gain substantially.
As regards the trade barriers, both India and Pakistan have had a very restrictive trade regime. But, during the last two decades both the countries have liberalized their trade regimes significantly by reducing tariffs, multiplicity of tariff types and slabs, regulatory duties, and exemptions. Also, other barriers on trade such as import licensing, improper valuation methodology, tariff rate quotas have also been removed or reduced. Nevertheless, the Indian trade regime is still more restrictive than its counterpart in Pakistan. According to an IMF study, India’s trade restrictiveness measures 8 (on a scale from 1 to 10), while Pakistan’s index stands at 6.


Likely implications for granting MFN status to India
The argument against MFN status is given by the stakeholders related to industrial sector and is of ‘infant industry’. It is asserted that the opening up of Pakistani market for all Indian products would hurt the domestic manufacturing sector. The arguments reflect that our industry is uncompetitive and inefficient relative to the Indian industry. It is expected that the Pakistani markets will glut with cheap Indian products and the domestic producers will not be able to compete due to lower prices. Specifically, the domestic auto and the electronics industry may face cut throat competition as the Indian industry is relatively well established and efficient. For the textiles sector, it is expected that since the Indian textiles industry is more into the domestic supply as compared to an export oriented Pakistani textile sector, the low cost textiles of India would wipe out the Pakistani textile production meant for the domestic consumer.
Two Common Misconceptions about MFN
Indian goods will flood Pakistani markets and ruin local producers: WTO provisions allow members to impose safeguards restricting imports (for temporary periods) should such imports unfairly or seriously injure domestic producers.
India and Pakistan’s political tensions will defeat smooth trade efforts: History suggests old enmities can be overcome by trade. Consider the end of the China-Taiwan fray, and the concomitant increase in trade from $8.1 billion in 1991 to $100 billion in 2010, as well as the US-Vietnam bilateral trade agreement in 2001, resulting in the US being the leading investor in Vietnam today.


Policy Options
Currently, business visas granted by India to Pakistani nationals are city specific, single entry and short duration. This limits what can be accomplished in one business trip. In this context, the recent report that India is considering moving towards a Preferential Trade Agreement with Pakistan and that a liberalized visa regime would be one of the first steps is particularly encouraging. Improve infrastructure, including warehousing facilities for perishables, better rail and cargo train services, and air links. Ease restrictions, such as the number of hours or the day of week when official trade across borders can occur.



Non-Food Spillover-Multifunctional- Benefits of Agriculture  WTO Regime

  • Asif Maqbool
  • Muhammad Rasheed


 Multifunctionality is an issue that has arisen in the new WTO negotiations on agriculture as part of the continuing discussions of distortions affecting agricultural markets and trade. Multifunctionality refers to the concept that, besides producing food and fiber, agriculture creates non-food joint or spillover—multifunctional—benefits such as open space, wildlife habitat, biodiversity, flood prevention, cultural heritage, viable rural communities, and food security. While the basic concept appears uncontroversial, multifunctionality has become the subject of debate in international forums because some countries seek to use multifunctionality to justify exemptions from WTO commitments to reduce their governments’ production-related support to agriculture. The new agricultural trade negotiations will continue the reform process with the long-term objective of achieving “substantial progressive reductions in support and protection resulting in fundamental reform.” As part of the built-in agenda of the Uruguay Round Agreement on Agriculture (URAA), WTO members agreed that the new negotiations would take into account “non-trade concerns,” including certain multifunctional issues like food security and the need to protect the environment. The WTO disciplines policies based on their effects on production and trade. In the URAA, countries agreed to reduce spending on domestic policies that distort production or trade, while policies that do not distort trade or are minimally trade distorting were exempt from reduction commitments. Some countries propose using policy objectives (i.e., whether the policy’s aim is to achieve a desired nonfood output) rather than its effects, as criteria for determining which policies to discipline. This approach could weaken WTO rules regulating domestic agricultural policies that distort international markets. On the other side of the debate, some countries maintain that objectives can be met with different policies, including many that are non- or minimally trade-distorting, and that the most efficient way to meet policy objectives is to target the policy to the objective.
Some countries have argued that production of food and nonfood outputs are closely linked in terms of the economic principle of “joint products.” A joint product, or jointness, characterizes a production relationship where two (or more) outputs are produced from the same production process. For example, hides and meat are joint products of cattle.  Proponents of this view maintain that the socially desired nonfood outputs, such as scenic farmlands, are produced jointly with agricultural production which is necessary to obtain the nonfood output. Some claim further that production-linked support for agriculture is necessary to achieve multifunctional benefits.
Opponents of this view argue that joint production relationships are not immutably fixed and can change over time with changes in technology. The jointness defense of production-linked agricultural support is argued to be inconsistent with the current WTO criteria that any policies exempt from disciplines be only minimally trade distorting. An alternative consistent with the reform process is to produce the desired nonfood outputs independently of agriculture through a range of policy instruments and private actions. For example, scenic farmland and open land can be produced through parkland or land used for recreational purposes (such as golf courses).  These uses could be undertaken by government or by private associations, and could be encouraged through favorable tax treatment.
Agricultural production activities can have positive (and negative) side effects, or externalities, that may not be accounted for in the market. For example, a positive externality of agricultural production might be flood protection, while the harmful effects of agricultural runoff on water quality would constitute a negative externality. In the multifunctionality debate, the existence of positive externalities is frequently cited as justification for government intervention in agriculture.
Similarly, some countries contend that some of these non-food “outputs,” such as cultural heritage and scenic farmlands, are public goods that require government support to ensure their supply. Countering this view is the fact that multifunctional services need not originate in agricultural support policies.
Efficient policies target the specific objective associated with the nonfood output, and are less likely to result in trade distortions. Production-linked policies that target the nonfood objective indirectly are more likely to have spillovers that distort production and trade. The principle of efficient policy design—that policies should be targeted to the objective—is inconsistent with the joint ness rationale for production-linked support.
Proponents of the joint production argument favor pursuing the desired nonfood output indirectly by supporting agricultural production, while efficient policy design suggests that the policy be targeted directly to nonfood objectives themselves, such as environmental or rural development goals. For example, preservation of agricultural land need not be accomplished indirectly through price support.  Alternative public policy instruments include specific programs for protecting farmland, conservation easements, and purchase of development rights. Private alternatives include land buyouts by private entities.
The issue for the multifunctionality debate is how to accommodate demand for nonfood benefits of agriculture while respecting fundamental principles of the GATT and the guidelines agreed to in the URAA. Options include the following:

  1. Use minimally trade distorting government (green box) policies to address non-trade concerns. The green box contains specific provisions for addressing non trade concerns, including support for rural communities and amenities and payments for environmental programs.  Countries seeking to preserve and increase multifunctional benefits can adopt policies that are among the wide range of options provided in the green box.
  2. Use trade-distorting (blue and amber box) policies with in agreed-upon WTO limits to achieve domestic policy objectives. Shifting some other expenditure to exempt (green box) programs would provide greater flexibility for a country to use trade-distorting support to achieve objectives linked with multifunctionality. 
  3. Private actions can increasingly be used to address a number of nonfood objectives. Private groups can be encouraged to undertake these actions through tax policies and other inducements.

Tuesday, December 30, 2014


Improvement in Present Cotton Supply Chain

  • Asif Maqbool 
  • Naeem Qasim
  • Muhammad Rasheed


Agriculture is the mainstay of Pakistan’s economy. Nearly one fourth of total output and 42 percent of total employment is generated in agriculture. It also contributes substantially to Pakistan’s exports. Agriculture also contributes to growth as a supplier of raw materials to industry as well as market for industrial products. Not only that 42 percent of country’s work force are employed in agriculture but 67.5 percent of country’s population living in rural areas is directly or indirectly linked with agriculture for their livelihood. Whatever happens to agriculture is bound to affect not only the country’s growth performance but to a large segment of the country’s population as well.
There are two principal crop seasons in Pakistan, namely the Kharif and the Rabi. Rice, Sugarcane, Cotton, Maize, Bajra and Jowar are Kharif crops while Wheat, Gram, Tobacco, Rapeseed, Barley and Mustard are Rabi crops. Cotton is the important non-food Kharif crop and a significant source of foreign exchange earning. It accounts for 10.5 percent of the value added in agriculture and about 2.4 percent of GDP. In addition to providing raw material to textile industry, surplus lint cotton is exported.  
Cotton crop which provides edible oil, feed and fibre, is the major cash crop of Pakistan and life line of the national economy. It makes a significant contribution to the economies of many major cotton producing states. It provides raw material to textile mills, ginning factories and oil expellers. As a result the livelihood of the millions of people depends on cotton and cotton based industry. It supports millions of faming families, laborers, pickers, ginners, spinners, weavers, finishers and hosieries, carpets, rugs and other allied industries. On these counts Pakistan economy may be termed as the fibre economy.
The present cotton scenario is exciting and holds even better prospects for future, both in terms of employment and exports. The performance of cotton crop affects the overall growth rate, import bill, and living standard of our farming community. It occupies a pivotal position for attaining national food security goals in the form of edible oil.
Production of cotton was provisionally estimated at 14618 thousand bales during 2004-05. The highest ever recorded in the country’s history, and up by 45.5 percent over the last year’s production of 10.0 million bales. Factors responsible for the unprecedented rise in cotton production include:  7.8 percent rise in area under the crop; higher ball bearings; use of improved quality of pesticide resulting in low pest pressures; and favourable weather condition for growth and development of the crop
 The progressive farmers obtain cotton yields ranging two to three times the national average yield which is 570.99 kg per hectare. No doubt, there was a significant increase in cotton productivity but still potential yield is not exploited. This means that existing technologies possess the needed capability to increase the cotton yield.
The gap between progressive farmers yield and the national average yield represents the untapped yield reservoir existing at the current level of technology. Highest priority should, therefore, be given to bridge the gap in order to produce enough to meet our future demand for fiber and edible oil. Highest yields at the experimental stations or the progressive farms prove that appropriate technologies best suited to our conditions are available and adoption of such technologies by progressive farmers is economical too.
Main Factors
A variety of factors either climatic or inputs affect cotton productivity. Some of the factors are discussed as under,
1. Biological factors: These factors result in low adoption of new technology by the farmers and thereby causing yield gap
2. Lack of trained manpower
3. Lack of finance
4. Lack of proper marketing facilities
5. High cost of agricultural inputs
Cotton management in complex farming systems is influenced by time conflicts in the harvesting of preceding crops and the sowing of cotton, and interactions due to residual effects on succeeding crops. It has estimated that timely availability of inputs such as seed, fertilizer, weedicides and pesticides could enhance crop productivity.
The paper is based on primary data collected through a comprehensive questionnaire from 75 cotton growers of Sargodha district. Cotton growers were selected randomly from three villages of the district. From each village, 25 farmers were interviewed for detailed information.
A regression equation was estimated assuming a modified Cobb-Douglas type production function for cotton in order to determine the contributions made by various inputs and managerial factors towards higher cotton productivity.
This study was designed to investigate the role of farmers’ management practices in achieving higher cotton productivity in Sargodha district. The assessed factors include education, land preparation, seed, irrigation, plant protection measures, nitrogen and phosphorus. The effects of these factors on cotton yield were investigated through multiple regression analysis. The Cobb Douglas type production function was estimated using the ordinary least square (OLS) method and the results are presented in table 1. 
The R2 value of 0.49 can be regarded as quite a good fit in view of the cross-sectional data involved in this study, since it implies that about 49 percent variation in yield is explained by the independent variables included in the model. The influence of the independent variables on cotton yield is discussed in detail as follows.
Education
Education plays a vital role in the adoption of improved technology and attaining higher productivity level. The results of the study indicate that coefficient of schooling year was positive (0.150) and was statistically significant at five percent probability level. This result indicates that one percent increase in schooling year could enhance cotton yield by 0.1502 percent. This increased yield would result due to better management practices and adoption of latest technologies in cotton cultivation. 
Land preparation
Cotton is a deep rooted and heavy feeding crop. It thus needs deeply tilled and well prepared soil for its tap root to penetrate deep into the soil and feeding roots to establish in the feeding zone. The results of the production function show that number of tractor hours for land preparation had a positive coefficient (0.153); and it was statistically significant at 10 percent probability level. The positive coefficient implies that well prepared land contributes significantly toward higher yield of cotton crop. 
Seed rate 
Given the other factors, seed rate determines the plant population in a field of certain crop and thus is an important factor in determining yield. The coefficient of seed rate was positive, however, it was statistically non-significant. It may be due to the fact that farmers were using seed according to recommended level.
Irrigation
Although statistically non-significant, the positive coefficient of number of irrigation implies that one percent increase in number of irrigation could enhance 0.101 percent higher yield of cotton crop. The reason for non-significance of number of irrigation was that the farmers were applying irrigation according to crop requirements.


Table 1: The Production Function Estimates of Cotton

Variables
Coefficients
t-value
Constant
2.481***
(0.349)
7.099
LnEDU
0.150**
(0.075)
1.998
LnLP
0.153*
(0.082)
1.868
LnSEED
0.308NS
(0.204)
0.961
LnIRR
0.101NS
(0.101)
1.008
LnPPM
0.244***
(0.048)
5.069
LnN
0.113**
(0.056)
2.037
LnP
0.184**
(0.082)
2.224

Figures in parenthesis are standard errors
NS=Non-significant *significant (P<0.10), ** Significant (P<0.05), *** highly significant (P<0.01) 
Dependent variable: Logarithm of yield in kg per acre
R2 = 0.49 F value = 6.24 Number of observation = 75
Plant protection measures
Plant protection measures include weeding, hoeing and application of pesticide to control pest and disease on cotton crop. The incidence of weeds, pests and disease on cotton crop is a growing problem in all cotton-growing areas of Pakistan and adoption of chemical control methods are increasingly becoming popular among the cotton growers. The results of the production function reveal that cost of plant protection measures had a positive coefficient (0.244) and it was statistically highly significant. This result indicates that additional cost of plant protection measures increases cotton yield significantly.
Fertilizer use
The recommendations regarding application of chemical fertilizers to cotton crop also emphasize the use of balance dose of fertilizers (N: P: K). Therefore, variables of P-nutrients and N-nutrients were included in the model.  The coefficients of nitrogen nutrient and phosphorus nutrient were positive and were statistically significant at five percent probability level. 
Conclusion and suggestions
There are many factors that affect cotton productivity, namely socio-economic, biological, managerial and physical. In this study, some important factors were taken into account to determine their effect on cotton productivity. These vital factors were schooling years of the respondents, land preparation, irrigation, seed rate, plant protection measures and fertilizer nutrients. All these factors were found positively contributing towards higher yield of cotton crop in Sargodha district. However, the effects of schooling year, land preparation, fertilizer and plant protection measures were significant.
Reorientation of breeding research is required to evolve high yielding, and disease resistant varieties for cotton. Moreover, extension systems should emphasize in training farmers to control weeds and disease and pest attack. Field visits and demonstration by extension staff could be right steps in the right direction. 
There is a need to emphasize research and extension strategies. The provision of sufficient resources to research and extension systems is suggested for developing and promoting new technologies to combat disease and pest attack on cotton crop.
Timely availability of quality inputs such as seed, phosphatic fertilizer, weedicides and pesticides play the key role in cotton productivity enhancement. The efforts of agencies and departments involved in the distribution and quality control of vital inputs need to be accentuated further. This would ensure timely availability and quality of these inputs to the cotton growers.

Monday, December 29, 2014

 Rural Development: Issues and Strategies



By Asif Maqbool



The concept of rural development has changed significantly during the last three decades. Until the 1970s, rural development was synonymous with agricultural development and, hence, focused on increasing agricultural production. Today’s concept of rural development concerns not only with improvements in growth, income, and output but it also includes an assessment of changes in the quality of life, such as improvement in health and nutrition, education, environmentally safe living conditions, and reduction in gender and income inequalities.
Overview of the Rural Development Programmes in Pakistan
Since its independence, Pakistan has embarked upon a number of rural and agricultural development programmes to increase the productivity and quality of life of rural people. These programes were Village Aid Programme, Basic Democracies system, Rural Works Programme, Integrated Rural Development, Peoples Works Programme, Local Govt. and Rural Development, Peoples Programme, Tameer-e-Watan, Social Action Programmes, Khushal Pakistan, Tameer-e-Pakistan and Khushal Pakistan Programme-1. These programmes were partially or fully extended to all parts of the country. The overall objectives of these programmes were the social welfare, improvement in quality of life and agricultural development. These programmes did not achieve the desired results because the objectives of one programme conflicted with those of others, and there was no institutional mechanism for reconciling them. Consequently, many programmes not only failed to produce the intended benefits, but also caused harm to other programmes.
Common causes of failure of these programmes were loose and uncoordinated institutional framework; lack of mutual understanding and collaboration within the nation-building departments and with the departments of rural development; absence of efforts to help evolve rural leadership from the grass roots; lack of proper supervision, follow-up, research and evaluation of projects.

Current Issues of Rural Sector

Rural scenario can generally be characterized as follows:
  1. Rural development policy always had a heavy bias towards large farmers, whereas small landholders making more than 90 percent of total farms were ignored along with landless labor community.
  2. Rigid cropping pattern prevailing in the country results in lack of intensification and diversification of agriculture sector, thereby increasing unemployment in rural areas.
  3. Natural resource base is deteriorating overtime. Due to inappropriate agricultural practices and climate change, land degradation is more and land productivity is declining. Almost 40 percent of land in Sindh alone has turned saline. The rangelands on which 70 percent of local livestock thrives have been degraded and no rehabilitation plans are in place.
  4. Literacy rate is very low in these areas and illiterate farmers cannot realize the benefits of modern, scientific and technical know-how in farming business. Moreover, rural areas are deprived of schools. In case, if schooling facilities are available, then qualified staff is not available. Basic health care is the prime need of every individual. Unfortunately, this component is totally ignored by the Govt. Most villages in Pakistan still are lacking in hospitals, dispensaries and other health centers. According to an estimate 70-80 million people do not have requisite access to education and health services.
  5. Poor health, malnutrition and high population growth rates are widespread in rural areas, badly affecting productivity. According to an estimate, 30-50 million people are malnourished.
  6. Water supply and sanitation condition is not satisfactory in rural areas. Population having access to safe water is 87 percent and 35 percent of total population has access to sanitation.
  7. Appropriate facilities for healthy activities are not available in rural areas. So, the frustrated young people indulge in obnoxious activities such as drug addiction, rape, robbery, murder, etc.
 Future Strategies
  •        To develop rural community to become active participants of the                        economy, the following steps needs to be prioritized:
  • 1.      The rural poor (small landholders and landless class)     need to participate in the development and        implementation of the relevant policies and programs. It requires institutional and technological reforms.
  • 2.      For sustainable rural development, conservation and development of natural resources, focusing on protection of environment and biodiversity must be undertaken.
  • 3.      Strengthening rural institutions in the country can satisfy the thrust for rural development. There is a need to address the issues of inequality in terms of resources along with the innovation and adoption of cost saving technologies.
  • 4.      There is a strong need to develop and promote agro-based industry in rural areas to create employment opportunities through private-public interventions. This will definitely help in reducing the rural urban migration on one hand and rural poverty on the other. It could be achieved by promoting savings in rural areas, thereby increasing investment opportunities for overall improvement in the income of the rural communities.
  • 5.      Proper monitoring and evaluation of rural development programmes must be carried out to ensure successful implementation of programme activities and those who are responsible for not achieving the results must be accounted for.
  • 6.      Initiatives must be taken to address the problems of public health and education for fast growing population. This demands for establishment of schools and health facilities on modern lines. Such facilities would provide productive, healthy and educated labour force to agriculture in particular and to the economy in general.

Conclusions

Pakistan had a very long history of Government intervention in the rural sector, with a view to improve the socio-economic condition of rural people, especially the poor. However, there is no comprehensive integrated national policy for agricultural and rural development yet declared and adopted by the Government. What is, therefore, needed is a long-term comprehensive integrated national policy, which clearly charts the future course of agricultural and rural development in the country in the twenty-first century. This is all the more necessary in the wake of new economic policy characterized by liberalization, privatization and globalization of Pakistan’s economy.



Sunday, December 28, 2014



Subsidies to Agriculture Sector in India, Pakistan and the World


  • Asif Maqbool
  • Naeem Qasim
  • Muhammed Rasheed


Indian Subsidies to Agriculture:
          
India appears to be subsidising heavily inputs into agricultural production, including fertilizers, electricity, irrigation, etc. According to WTO [2011] the total subsidies in 2008-09 aggregated to $53 billion, over 5 percent of the GDP (as shown in Table No.1) and have probably continued to show rapid growth upto 2010-11. The subsidy per hectare was almost $300. The comparable figures for Pakistan (see Table 4.1) for 2010-11 are agricultural subsidies of $2.7 billion, equivalent to 1.2 percent of the GDP and per hectare of $118. Therefore, agricultural subsidies are almost three times higher in India in comparison to Pakistan. This has artificially raised the competitiveness of agricultural products to India. The Indian subsidies on agriculture are WTO compliant but they do represent a NTB and have substantially limited the prospects of Pakistani exports of agricultural products to India (as was the case at the time of Partition).
The level of subsidies as a percentage of the value of agricultural production is 15 percent.
Table No.1
SUBSIDIES TO AGRICULTURAL INPUTS IN INDIA
(billion $)

2006-07
20081-09
Growth rate
(%)
Fertilizer
16.0
35.0
54.1
Electricity
4.7
6.0
18.1
Irrigation
4.0
5.2
18.0
Othera
1.1
7.2
162.9
TOTAL SUBSIDIES
25.8
53.4
50.0
Memo items:







Agricultural Value Added
196.3
232.1

Agricultural Production**
294.5
348.2

GDP* (at current prices)
927.6
1018.9

Cropped Area (Million Hectares)
178.4
179.3





Subsidies as % of value Added in Agriculture
13
23

Subsidies as % of GNP
2.8
5.2

Subsidy per hectare ($)
145
297

Subsidy as % of Value Of Production
8.8 %
15.3 %

Source: WTO Trade Policy Review
               India Economic Survey, MOF.
*GNP at current prices
** 1.5 is ratio of production to value added



Subsidies by Pakistan to Agriculture
As part of the project, current estimates of the level of subsidies on inputs into agriculture have been derived, perhaps for the first time. The results are presented in Table No.2
Table No.2
SUBSIDIES ON AGRICULTURAL INPUTS IN PAKISTAN, 2010-11

(Million $)
Fertilizer Subsidy
1014
on imports
525
on domestic production1
501
Power Subsidy
944
Irrigation Subsidy
711
Others (tractors, seeds, etc)
7
TOTAL SUBSIDY
2676
Memo items:



Agricultural Value Added
43088
GNP (at current prices)
219732
Cropped Area (million hectares)
22.75


Subsidies as % of Value Added
6.2
Subsidies as % of GNP
1.2
Subsidy per hectare ($)
118
Subsidies as % of Value of Production
4.9
Source: Federal and Provincial Budget Documents,
Agricultural Statistics Year Book,
Pakistan Economic Survey
1 in the form of lower price of natural gas
The total subsidy bill is estimated at  $2.7 billion, in 2010-11. The largest component is the fertilizer subsidy followed by the subsidy on electricity consumption (especially by tubewells) in agriculture. Subsidies to agriculture stand at 1.2 percent of GNP and amount to $118 per hectare. It is estimated that the level of subsidy per hectare is almost three times higher in India compared to Pakistan.

Agricultural Subsidies in the World



European Union



In 2010, the EU spent €57 billion on agricultural development, of which €39 billion was spent on direct subsidies. Agricultural and fisheries subsidies form over 40% of the EU budget. Since 1992 (and especially since 2005), the EU's Common Agricultural Policy has undergone significant change as subsidies have mostly been decoupled from production. The largest subsidy is the Single Farm Payment.

Africa


Increases in food and fertilizer prices have underlined the vulnerability of poor urban and rural households in many developing countries, especially in Africa, renewing policymakers' focus on the need to increase staple food crop productivity.
A study by the Overseas Development Institute evaluates the benefits of the Malawi Government Agricultural Inputs Subsidy Programme, which was implemented in 2006/2007 to promote access to and use of fertilizers in both maize and tobacco production to increase agricultural productivity and food security. The subsidy was implemented by means of a coupon system which could be redeemed by the recipients for fertilizer types at approximately one-third of the normal cash price. According to policy conclusions of the Overseas Development Institute the voucher for coupon system can be an effective way of rationing and targeting subsidy access to maximize production and economic and social gains. Many practical and political challenges remain in the program design and implementation required to increase efficiency, control costs, and limit patronage and fraud.

New Zealand

New Zealand is reputed to have the most open agricultural markets in the world after radical reforms started in 1984 by the Fourth Labour Government stopped all subsidies.
"In 1984 New Zealand's Labor government took the dramatic step of ending all farm subsidies, which then consisted of 30 separate production payments and export incentives. This was a truly striking policy action, because New Zealand's economy is roughly five times more dependent on farming than is the U.S. economy, measured by either output or employment. Subsidies in New Zealand accounted for more than 30 percent of the value of production before reform, somewhat higher than U.S. subsidies today. And New Zealand farming was marred by the same problems caused by U.S. subsidies, including overproduction, environmental degradation and inflated land prices."
As the country is a large agricultural exporter, continued subsidies by other countries are a long-standing bone of contention, with New Zealand being a founding member of the 19-member Cairns Group fighting to improve market access for exported agricultural goods.


United States


The United States currently pays around $20 billion per year to farmers in direct subsidies as "farm income stabilization" via U.S. farm bills. These bills pre-date the economic turmoil of the Great Depression with the 1922 Grain Futures Act, the 1929 Agricultural Marketing Act and the 1933 Agricultural Adjustment Act creating a tradition of government support.
The beneficiaries of the subsidies have changed as agriculture in the United States has changed. In the 1930s, about 25% of the country's population resided on the nation's 6,000,000 small farms. By 1997, 157,000 large farms accounted for 72% of farm sales, with only 2% of the U.S. population residing on farms. In 2006, the top 3 states receiving subsidies were Texas (10.4%), Iowa (9.0%), and Illinois (7.6%). The Total USDA Subsidies from farms in Iowa totaled $1,212,000,000 in 2006. From 2003 to 2005 the top 1% of beneficiaries received 17% of subsidy payments In Texas, 72% of farms do not receive government subsidies. Of the close to $1.4 Billion in subsidy payments to farms in Texas, roughly 18% of the farms receive a portion of the payments.
"Direct payment subsidies are provided without regard to the economic need of the recipients or the financial condition of the farm economy. Established in 1996, direct payments were originally meant to wean farmers off traditional subsidies that are triggered during periods of low prices for corn, wheat, soybeans, cotton, rice, and other crops."
Top states for direct payments were Iowa ($501 million), Illinois ($454 million), and Texas ($397 million). Direct payments of subsidies are limited to $40,000 per person or $80,000 per couple.
The subsidy programs give farmers extra money for their crops and guarantee a price floor. For instance in the 2002 Farm Bill, for every bushel of wheat sold, farmers were paid an extra 52 cents and guaranteed a price of 3.86 from 2002–03 and 3.92 from 2004–2007. That is, if the price of wheat in 2002 was $3.80, farmers would get an extra 58¢ per bushel (52¢ plus the 6¢ price difference).

Corn is the top crop for subsidy payments. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 mandates that billions of gallons of ethanol be blended into vehicle fuel each year, guaranteeing demand, but US corn ethanol subsidies are between $5.5 billion and $7.3 billion per year. Producers also benefitted from a federal subsidy of 51 cents per gallon, additional state subsidies, and federal crop subsidies that can bring the total to 85 cents per gallon or more. However, the federal ethanol subsidy expired December 31, 2011. (US corn-ethanol producers were shielded from competition from cheaper Brazilian sugarcane-ethanol by a 54-cent-per-gallon tariff, however that tariff also expired December 31, 2011.

2004 U.S. Crop Subsidies
Commodity
Millions of US$
Share
Feed grains, mostly corn
2,841
35.4%
Upland cotton and ELS cotton
1,420
17.7%
Wheat
1,173
14.6%
Rice
1,130
14.1%
Soybeans and products
610
7.6%
Dairy
295
3.7%
Peanuts
259
3.2%
Sugar
61
0.8%
Minor oilseeds
29
0.4%
Tobacco
18
0.2%
Wool and mohair
12
0.1%
Vegetable oil products
11
0.1%
Honey
3
0.0%
Other crops
160
2.0%
Total
8,022
100%

Asia

Farm subsidies in Asia remain a point of contention in global trade talks.
In 2009, Japan paid USD$46.5 billion in subsidies to its farmers and continued state support of farmers in Japan remains a controversial topic.

South Korea has made attempts to reform its agricultural sector, despite resistance from vested interests.