Non-Food Spillover-Multifunctional- Benefits of Agriculture WTO Regime
- Asif Maqbool
- Muhammad Rasheed
Multifunctionality is an issue that has arisen
in the new WTO negotiations on agriculture as part of the continuing discussions
of distortions affecting agricultural markets and trade. Multifunctionality
refers to the concept that, besides producing food and fiber, agriculture
creates non-food joint or spillover—multifunctional—benefits such as open
space, wildlife habitat, biodiversity, flood prevention, cultural heritage,
viable rural communities, and food security. While the basic concept appears
uncontroversial, multifunctionality has become the subject of debate in international
forums because some countries seek to use multifunctionality to justify
exemptions from WTO commitments to reduce their governments’ production-related
support to agriculture. The new agricultural trade negotiations will continue
the reform process with the long-term objective of achieving “substantial
progressive reductions in support and protection resulting in fundamental
reform.” As part of the built-in agenda of the Uruguay Round Agreement on Agriculture
(URAA), WTO members agreed that the new negotiations would take into account
“non-trade concerns,” including certain multifunctional issues like food security
and the need to protect the environment. The WTO disciplines policies based on
their effects on production and trade. In the URAA, countries agreed to reduce
spending on domestic policies that distort production or trade, while policies
that do not distort trade or are minimally trade distorting were exempt from
reduction commitments. Some countries propose using policy objectives (i.e.,
whether the policy’s aim is to achieve a desired nonfood output) rather than
its effects, as criteria for determining which policies to discipline. This approach
could weaken WTO rules regulating domestic agricultural policies that distort
international markets. On the other side of the debate, some countries maintain
that objectives can be met with different policies, including many that are
non- or minimally trade-distorting, and that the most efficient way to meet
policy objectives is to target the policy to the objective.
Some countries
have argued that production of food and nonfood outputs are closely linked in
terms of the economic principle of “joint products.” A joint product, or
jointness, characterizes a production relationship where two (or more) outputs
are produced from the same production process. For example, hides and meat are
joint products of cattle. Proponents of
this view maintain that the socially desired nonfood outputs, such as scenic
farmlands, are produced jointly with agricultural production which is necessary
to obtain the nonfood output. Some claim further that production-linked support
for agriculture is necessary to achieve multifunctional benefits.
Opponents of
this view argue that joint production relationships are not immutably fixed and
can change over time with changes in technology. The jointness defense of production-linked
agricultural support is argued to be inconsistent with the current WTO criteria
that any policies exempt from disciplines be only minimally trade distorting.
An alternative consistent with the reform process is to produce the desired
nonfood outputs independently of agriculture through a range of policy
instruments and private actions. For example, scenic farmland and open land can
be produced through parkland or land used for recreational purposes (such as
golf courses). These uses could be undertaken
by government or by private associations, and could be encouraged through
favorable tax treatment.
Agricultural
production activities can have positive (and negative) side effects, or externalities,
that may not be accounted for in the market. For example, a positive externality
of agricultural production might be flood protection, while the harmful effects
of agricultural runoff on water quality would constitute a negative
externality. In the multifunctionality debate, the existence of positive externalities
is frequently cited as justification for government intervention in
agriculture.
Similarly, some
countries contend that some of these non-food “outputs,” such as cultural
heritage and scenic farmlands, are public goods that require government support
to ensure their supply. Countering this view is the fact that multifunctional
services need not originate in agricultural support policies.
Efficient
policies target the specific objective associated with the nonfood output, and
are less likely to result in trade distortions. Production-linked policies that
target the nonfood objective indirectly are more likely to have spillovers that
distort production and trade. The principle of efficient policy design—that
policies should be targeted to the objective—is inconsistent with the joint
ness rationale for production-linked support.
Proponents of
the joint production argument favor pursuing the desired nonfood output
indirectly by supporting agricultural production, while efficient policy design
suggests that the policy be targeted directly to nonfood objectives themselves,
such as environmental or rural development goals. For example, preservation of
agricultural land need not be accomplished indirectly through price support. Alternative public policy instruments include
specific programs for protecting farmland, conservation easements, and purchase
of development rights. Private alternatives include land buyouts by private
entities.
The issue for
the multifunctionality debate is how to accommodate demand for nonfood benefits
of agriculture while respecting fundamental principles of the GATT and the
guidelines agreed to in the URAA. Options include the following:
- Use minimally trade distorting government (green box) policies to address non-trade concerns. The green box contains specific provisions for addressing non trade concerns, including support for rural communities and amenities and payments for environmental programs. Countries seeking to preserve and increase multifunctional benefits can adopt policies that are among the wide range of options provided in the green box.
- Use trade-distorting (blue and amber box) policies with in agreed-upon WTO limits to achieve domestic policy objectives. Shifting some other expenditure to exempt (green box) programs would provide greater flexibility for a country to use trade-distorting support to achieve objectives linked with multifunctionality.
- Private actions can increasingly be used to address a number of nonfood objectives. Private groups can be encouraged to undertake these actions through tax policies and other inducements.
No comments:
Post a Comment