Subsidies to Agriculture Sector in India, Pakistan and the World
- Asif Maqbool
- Naeem Qasim
- Muhammed Rasheed
Indian
Subsidies to Agriculture:
India appears to
be subsidising heavily inputs into agricultural production, including
fertilizers, electricity, irrigation, etc. According to WTO [2011] the total
subsidies in 2008-09 aggregated to $53 billion, over 5 percent of the GDP (as
shown in Table No.1) and have probably continued to show rapid growth upto
2010-11. The subsidy per hectare was almost $300. The comparable figures for
Pakistan (see Table 4.1) for 2010-11 are agricultural subsidies of $2.7
billion, equivalent to 1.2 percent of the GDP and per hectare of $118.
Therefore, agricultural subsidies are almost three times higher in India in
comparison to Pakistan. This has artificially raised the competitiveness of
agricultural products to India. The Indian subsidies on agriculture are WTO
compliant but they do represent a NTB and have substantially limited the
prospects of Pakistani exports of agricultural products to India (as was the
case at the time of Partition).
The
level of subsidies as a percentage of the value of agricultural production is
15 percent.
Table No.1
SUBSIDIES
TO AGRICULTURAL INPUTS IN INDIA
(billion $)
|
|||
2006-07
|
20081-09
|
Growth rate
(%)
|
|
Fertilizer
|
16.0
|
35.0
|
54.1
|
Electricity
|
4.7
|
6.0
|
18.1
|
Irrigation
|
4.0
|
5.2
|
18.0
|
Othera
|
1.1
|
7.2
|
162.9
|
TOTAL
SUBSIDIES
|
25.8
|
53.4
|
50.0
|
Memo
items:
|
|||
Agricultural
Value Added
|
196.3
|
232.1
|
|
Agricultural
Production**
|
294.5
|
348.2
|
|
GDP*
(at current prices)
|
927.6
|
1018.9
|
|
Cropped
Area (Million Hectares)
|
178.4
|
179.3
|
|
Subsidies
as % of value Added in Agriculture
|
13
|
23
|
|
Subsidies
as % of GNP
|
2.8
|
5.2
|
|
Subsidy
per hectare ($)
|
145
|
297
|
|
Subsidy
as % of Value Of Production
|
8.8 %
|
15.3 %
|
|
Source: WTO Trade Policy Review
India Economic Survey, MOF.
*GNP at current prices
** 1.5 is
ratio of production to value added
|
|||
Subsidies
by Pakistan to Agriculture
As part of the
project, current estimates of the level of subsidies on inputs into agriculture
have been derived, perhaps for the first time. The results are presented in
Table No.2
Table
No.2
SUBSIDIES ON AGRICULTURAL
INPUTS IN PAKISTAN, 2010-11
|
|
(Million
$)
|
|
Fertilizer Subsidy
|
1014
|
on
imports
|
525
|
on
domestic production1
|
501
|
Power Subsidy
|
944
|
Irrigation Subsidy
|
711
|
Others (tractors,
seeds, etc)
|
7
|
TOTAL SUBSIDY
|
2676
|
Memo items:
|
|
Agricultural
Value Added
|
43088
|
GNP
(at current prices)
|
219732
|
Cropped
Area (million hectares)
|
22.75
|
Subsidies
as % of Value Added
|
6.2
|
Subsidies
as % of GNP
|
1.2
|
Subsidy
per hectare ($)
|
118
|
Subsidies
as % of Value of Production
|
4.9
|
Source:
Federal and Provincial Budget Documents,
Agricultural Statistics Year Book,
Pakistan Economic Survey
1
in the form of lower price of natural gas
|
|
The total subsidy
bill is estimated at $2.7 billion, in 2010-11.
The largest component is the fertilizer subsidy followed by the subsidy on
electricity consumption (especially by tubewells) in agriculture. Subsidies to
agriculture stand at 1.2 percent of GNP and amount to $118 per hectare. It is
estimated that the level of subsidy per hectare is almost three times higher in
India compared to Pakistan.
Agricultural Subsidies in the World
European Union
In 2010, the EU spent €57 billion on agricultural development, of which €39 billion was spent on direct subsidies. Agricultural and fisheries subsidies form over 40% of the EU budget. Since 1992 (and especially since 2005), the EU's Common Agricultural Policy has undergone significant change as subsidies have mostly been decoupled from production. The largest subsidy is the Single Farm Payment.
Africa
Increases in food and fertilizer prices have underlined the vulnerability of poor urban and rural households in many developing countries, especially in Africa, renewing policymakers' focus on the need to increase staple food crop productivity.
A study by the Overseas Development Institute evaluates the benefits of the Malawi Government Agricultural Inputs Subsidy Programme, which was implemented in 2006/2007 to promote access to and use of fertilizers in both maize and tobacco production to increase agricultural productivity and food security. The subsidy was implemented by means of a coupon system which could be redeemed by the recipients for fertilizer types at approximately one-third of the normal cash price. According to policy conclusions of the Overseas Development Institute the voucher for coupon system can be an effective way of rationing and targeting subsidy access to maximize production and economic and social gains. Many practical and political challenges remain in the program design and implementation required to increase efficiency, control costs, and limit patronage and fraud.
New Zealand
New Zealand is reputed to have the most open agricultural markets in the world after radical reforms started in 1984 by the Fourth Labour Government stopped all subsidies.
"In 1984 New Zealand's Labor government took the dramatic step of ending all farm subsidies, which then consisted of 30 separate production payments and export incentives. This was a truly striking policy action, because New Zealand's economy is roughly five times more dependent on farming than is the U.S. economy, measured by either output or employment. Subsidies in New Zealand accounted for more than 30 percent of the value of production before reform, somewhat higher than U.S. subsidies today. And New Zealand farming was marred by the same problems caused by U.S. subsidies, including overproduction, environmental degradation and inflated land prices."
As the country is a large agricultural exporter, continued subsidies by other countries are a long-standing bone of contention, with New Zealand being a founding member of the 19-member Cairns Group fighting to improve market access for exported agricultural goods.
United States
The United States currently pays around $20 billion per year to farmers in direct subsidies as "farm income stabilization" via U.S. farm bills. These bills pre-date the economic turmoil of the Great Depression with the 1922 Grain Futures Act, the 1929 Agricultural Marketing Act and the 1933 Agricultural Adjustment Act creating a tradition of government support.
The beneficiaries of the subsidies have changed as agriculture in the United States has changed. In the 1930s, about 25% of the country's population resided on the nation's 6,000,000 small farms. By 1997, 157,000 large farms accounted for 72% of farm sales, with only 2% of the U.S. population residing on farms. In 2006, the top 3 states receiving subsidies were Texas (10.4%), Iowa (9.0%), and Illinois (7.6%). The Total USDA Subsidies from farms in Iowa totaled $1,212,000,000 in 2006. From 2003 to 2005 the top 1% of beneficiaries received 17% of subsidy payments In Texas, 72% of farms do not receive government subsidies. Of the close to $1.4 Billion in subsidy payments to farms in Texas, roughly 18% of the farms receive a portion of the payments.
"Direct payment subsidies are provided without regard to the economic need of the recipients or the financial condition of the farm economy. Established in 1996, direct payments were originally meant to wean farmers off traditional subsidies that are triggered during periods of low prices for corn, wheat, soybeans, cotton, rice, and other crops."
Top states for direct payments were Iowa ($501 million), Illinois ($454 million), and Texas ($397 million). Direct payments of subsidies are limited to $40,000 per person or $80,000 per couple.
The subsidy programs give farmers extra money for their crops and guarantee a price floor. For instance in the 2002 Farm Bill, for every bushel of wheat sold, farmers were paid an extra 52 cents and guaranteed a price of 3.86 from 2002–03 and 3.92 from 2004–2007. That is, if the price of wheat in 2002 was $3.80, farmers would get an extra 58¢ per bushel (52¢ plus the 6¢ price difference).
Corn is the top crop for subsidy payments. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 mandates that billions of gallons of ethanol be blended into vehicle fuel each year, guaranteeing demand, but US corn ethanol subsidies are between $5.5 billion and $7.3 billion per year. Producers also benefitted from a federal subsidy of 51 cents per gallon, additional state subsidies, and federal crop subsidies that can bring the total to 85 cents per gallon or more. However, the federal ethanol subsidy expired December 31, 2011. (US corn-ethanol producers were shielded from competition from cheaper Brazilian sugarcane-ethanol by a 54-cent-per-gallon tariff, however that tariff also expired December 31, 2011.
2004 U.S. Crop Subsidies
|
||
Commodity
|
Millions of US$
|
Share
|
Feed grains, mostly corn
|
2,841
|
35.4%
|
Upland cotton and ELS
cotton
|
1,420
|
17.7%
|
Wheat
|
1,173
|
14.6%
|
Rice
|
1,130
|
14.1%
|
Soybeans and products
|
610
|
7.6%
|
Dairy
|
295
|
3.7%
|
Peanuts
|
259
|
3.2%
|
Sugar
|
61
|
0.8%
|
Minor oilseeds
|
29
|
0.4%
|
Tobacco
|
18
|
0.2%
|
Wool and mohair
|
12
|
0.1%
|
Vegetable oil products
|
11
|
0.1%
|
Honey
|
3
|
0.0%
|
Other crops
|
160
|
2.0%
|
Total
|
8,022
|
100%
|
Asia
Farm subsidies in Asia remain a point of contention in
global trade talks.
In 2009, Japan paid USD$46.5 billion in subsidies to its
farmers and continued state
support of farmers in Japan remains a controversial topic.
South Korea has made attempts to reform its agricultural
sector, despite resistance from vested interests.