PAKISTAN VS INDIA: MFN TREARTMENT AND IMPLICATIONS
- Asif Maqbool
- Muhammad Rasheed
Trade relations between India and Pakistan appear set to improve
significantly with Pakistan to grant India Most Favored Nation (MFN) status. Trade between India
and Pakistan
is as old as the two countries are, but the volume of trade between them is
very small relative to the size of their economies. However, this has not
always been the case. After 1947, Pakistan ’s exports and imports with
India
remained quite significant for several years, as high as 30 percent of exports
and 10 percent of imports. The
potential gains from easier trading relations are considerable for both
countries. In 2009-10, official trade between the two stood at $2 billion.
Studies suggest this volume could be much higher, absent formal and informal
barriers. For instance, a recent SAARC report estimates trade potential to be $12 billion.
All WTO
members are bound to grant MFN treatment to member countries with respect to
trade in goods. India granted Pakistan MFN status in 1996, but Pakistan held
back, citing strategic considerations. SAU has been using the granting
of MFN as a tool to achieve various objectives with respect to various
countries, such as China ,
Cuba ,
Iran ,
and Libya ,
for years.
Despite granting Pakistan MFN status, India continued to impose high
tariffs on goods of interest to Pakistan—textiles and leather. Thus, merely
according MFN status does not imply easier trade. So, does Pakistan’s offer
matter? Yes, it does. It signals enthusiasm, goodwill, and a
keenness to build peaceful and productive economic and political relations in
the region.
The gains are likely to come from existing markets as well as new ones. The
former includes informal (illegal) trade, conducted through cross border
smuggling and personal baggage — and according to some estimates, worth $13
billion. It also includes trade to the tune of $3-3.5 billion conducted through
third-parties, such as Dubai, since direct trade is difficult. The potential
for new markets is tremendous. For instance, a Government College University
study suggests expanding Pakistan’s light engineering sector. The same study
suggests that India has a relative advantage in bicycle production, which it
could export to Pakistan. Additionally, as FICCI secretary–general, Rajiv Kumar
notes, if Indian goods are permitted to transit through Pakistan and access
Central Asian markets, then traders in Haryana, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and
North Rajasthan stand to gain substantially.
As regards the trade barriers, both India and Pakistan have
had a very restrictive trade regime. But, during the last two decades both the
countries have liberalized their trade regimes significantly by reducing
tariffs, multiplicity of tariff types and slabs, regulatory duties, and
exemptions. Also, other barriers on trade such as import licensing, improper
valuation methodology, tariff rate quotas have also been removed or reduced.
Nevertheless, the Indian trade regime is still more restrictive than its
counterpart in Pakistan .
According to an IMF study, India ’s
trade restrictiveness measures 8 (on a scale from 1 to 10), while Pakistan ’s
index stands at 6.
Likely implications for granting MFN
status to India
The argument against MFN status is given by the
stakeholders related to industrial sector and is of ‘infant industry’. It is
asserted that the opening up of Pakistani market for all Indian products would
hurt the domestic manufacturing sector. The arguments reflect that our industry
is uncompetitive and inefficient relative to the Indian industry. It is
expected that the Pakistani markets will glut with cheap Indian products and
the domestic producers will not be able to compete due to lower prices.
Specifically, the domestic auto and the electronics industry may face cut throat
competition as the Indian industry is relatively well established and
efficient. For the textiles sector, it is expected that since the Indian
textiles industry is more into the domestic supply as compared to an export
oriented Pakistani textile sector, the low cost textiles of India would
wipe out the Pakistani textile production meant for the domestic consumer.
Two Common Misconceptions about MFN
Indian goods will flood Pakistani markets and ruin
local producers: WTO
provisions allow members to impose safeguards restricting imports (for
temporary periods) should such imports unfairly or seriously injure domestic
producers.
India and Pakistan’s political tensions will
defeat smooth trade efforts: History suggests old enmities can be overcome by trade. Consider the end
of the China-Taiwan fray, and the concomitant increase in trade from $8.1
billion in 1991 to $100 billion in 2010, as well as the US-Vietnam bilateral
trade agreement in 2001, resulting in the US being the leading investor in
Vietnam today.
Policy Options
Currently, business visas granted by India to Pakistani nationals are city
specific, single entry and short duration. This limits what can be accomplished
in one business trip. In this context, the recent report that India is
considering moving towards a Preferential Trade Agreement with Pakistan and
that a liberalized visa regime would be one of the first steps is particularly
encouraging. Improve
infrastructure, including warehousing facilities for
perishables, better rail and cargo train services, and air links. Ease restrictions,
such as the number of hours or the day of week when official trade across
borders can occur.