Showing posts with label Poverty and Human Development. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Poverty and Human Development. Show all posts

Sunday, December 28, 2014


Poverty and Human Development: Challenges and Opportunities

 Asif Maqbool 

Poverty is a situation that cannot be described it can only be felt. One knows more about poverty when he is hungry and cannot purchase food. He and his children want new cloths on festivals but he cannot purchase it due to low income. He is sick and does not have any money to have medicine. He wants to send his children to school but cannot bear educational expenditures. So poverty is actually, hunger, lack of shelter, having no job, fear for the future. Poverty is powerlessness lack of freedom and representation of common people.

Human development report (HDR 2006/07-08) tells us that South Asia is the only region overall the world that has reduced poverty from 38 percent to 29 percent in recent years. South Asia’s share (having countries like Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan and Maldives) in world’s population is 22 percent.  It has more than 40 percent poor people of the world.  62 percent people living here are without basic facilities of life. Half a billion population of South Asia is living below poverty line that is one dollar a day.  55 percent of women in South Asia are still illiterate, and about 62 percent children are under nourished.

In our neighbors, India is the major country with highest population, economic growth and in its IT related boom. But more than 80 percent people there are living below poverty line that is two dollar a day. And 34 percent people are below poverty line if we consider one dollar a day as poverty line.

Here, in Pakistan poverty remains a serious concern. Poverty rate had fallen in 1960’s but in 1990’s it again started to rise due to corruption and poor federal policies. According to Economic Survey of Pakistan 2007, 23.9 percent people are below poverty line (i.e. 1 $ a day) and from other non-official resources and agencies it lies between 25.7 percent to 28.3 percent. And if we consider 2 $ a day as poverty line more that 75 percent people are below poverty line. Actually poverty has many dimensions in Pakistan. It is not just due to low income (income poverty) but also suffering from lack of access over basic needs of food, cloth and shelter.

Poverty has its strong linkage with human development. Because human development is actually a process of enlarging the range of people’s choices, increasing their opportunities for education health care , income, employment and covering their full range of human choices and giving full economic and political freedom to people and all this depends upon
  • Enjoying a long and healthy life
  • Acquiring knowledge
  • Having access to resources
  • Having freedom exercise choices and participation in society

Enjoying a healthy life with proper health care facilities at a low cost is the basic need of every person. Access to knowledge or information is essential for sustainable development, political stability and participation of people in policy making help in human development and ultimately can reduce poverty. Reduction in poverty helps in growth, by enabling poor to participate productively in economy.

So human development basically depends upon
  • Economic growth
  • Social development

Human development can be measured as Human Development Index (HDI), which is a measure of life expectancy, literacy, education, standard of living and GDP per capita etc. According to Human Development Report (HDR 2006/07-08) Pakistan has 0.551 HDI that is lower than India 0.619, but higher than Bangladesh 0.547. Higher HDI shows more human development and less poverty of that country.
In Pakistan in spite of high growth rate of more than 7 percent in recent years there are still large number of challenges that are responsible for poverty and low human development.
Challenges and opportunities

First major challenge is of food security, which is at national level may be described as satisfactory balance between food supply and food demand at reasonable prices. The imbalance between them due to rising prices may mean that some households are food insecure. Although per capita income is increasing over the year yet it is not indicative of the fact that majority of the population is food secure. It is reported that purchasing power of the poor has declined by 50 percent and poor spend up to 75 percent or more of their incomes on food items. And now due to recent wheat crisis Pakistan is becoming more food insecure country. Reason is not just that we are producing less but another major reason is due to wronged estimates and mismanagement of buffer stocks, we are facing this problem. And the extent of shortage is not known until the new crop reaches the market so food shortage is a big challenge for government these days.

Inflation is another major challenge to poverty. High inflation due to irresponsible policies of our government are continuously increasing prices of food items, raw materials, fuel, and manufacturing goods. Increase in sales tax every year also raises the prices of goods and services. Although, Inflation results in wages and incomes of people but on the other side it also increases the prices of utilities, and result in insufficiently tight financial policies, with a high budget deficit and devaluation of currency and higher agricultural support prices. As, it is happening now days in our country, fuel prices like crude oil prices are touching record high peaks and these is adding fuel to fire. Day by day fluctuation in prices of oil is affecting all other commodities increasing their transportation cost and all burdens have to be bare by consumer. Under these circumstances, one wonders whom to blame for this massive price hike.

Human development measurement also includes healthcare facilities available to people. Poor access to affordable health has made our people less resilient to economic hardships and more vulnerable to poverty. We can say Malaria and tuberculosis are the diseases as a result of poverty. Health and nutritional status of Pakistan’s population is among the worst in developing nations. According to several indicators like Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) per 1000 birth in 2003 for Pakistan was 95.3 percent, in contrast with China 41.4, India 72.5, and Sri Lanka 22.9. In terms of health and nutritional inputs, according to Health Survey of Pakistan (HSP) 2005, only one doctor is available to 1446 people and 3347 people have only one nurse.

Growth activities are very much necessary for human development especially for infrastructure development. And infrastructure development, leads to human development by reducing poverty. In Pakistan almost all rural people depend on agriculture sector. So rural development is needed more but data shows that during last 15 years poverty has been decreased more in urban areas than in rural areas. In 1990-92 it was 24.5 percent in rural areas and 28.3 percent in urban areas but in 2006-07 it is 39 percent and 22.7 percent respectively showing more concentration of development activities in urban areas than in rural areas.

 In spite of presence of large amount of funds and expenditures for development in budget the life of poor could not be improved so much. Because when the beneficiaries are not the poor but the people who govern them indicate the failure of governance, which is the major hindrance in development.

Water shortage is the hottest issue now a days. The most dreaded water scarcity event has at last hit Pakistan. There was nothing unexpected. The manner, which we have been used to handle our resources and national affairs, this catastrophic occurrence, was bound to take us over. Nature’s endowment of water blessings upon Pakistan has always been envied the world at large.  At the time of independence 5000 Cu/m of water was available to each Pakistani. Which has now reduced to 1000 Cu/m, because of uncontrolled population and misuse? And this water scarcity also leads to electricity shortage which now a days our country is facing. And all this adversely affects working of industries, which directly affects the wages of laborers and may cause more unemployment leading to poverty.

Water has also its use for irrigation purposes in agriculture sector. Climatic changes and water shortage has resulted in reduced production of our major crops leading to food security problems. It is noted that poverty is always high in non-irrigated areas. In irrigated areas its average is 34 percent, which is still very high and just because of unequal distribution of water.

The unequal distribution of land and feudal system is also a reason to poverty in Pakistan. Almost 75 percent households have their no own land. And more than 90 percent farmers are small farmers which are more productive than remaining land lords. But they cannot use high-powered machinery on their lands and have much less resources. Land reform act already done in Pakistan did not benefited, as they should be, just due to policies of different governments in favor of landlords. But if properly done can help in eliminating poverty in real sense by generating more income to small farmers.
Taking loans or credits is also difficult for poor to start their own business at small scale because of higher interest rates. Complex procedure in taking credit is also a reason for illiterate people especially farmers.

 Increasing population and low education level is also a reason for poverty. It is said that if there is a 3 percent increase in population than it requires a 9 percent increase in economic growth for a developed nation. But is that happening in Pakistan? No. our population is increasing at a much higher rate of 1.9 percent and it is also estimated that in next 37 years Pakistan’s population will be double of its present population. But our resources are continuously depleting and we are doing no effort to enhance or save our resources. So in this situation we have to be ready for serious consequences of frustration, unemployment, social crimes, bribery, hoarding, and food inflation.

To cope with these major challenges some possible solutions are:

Micro finance is an important instrument in alleviating poverty and for human development especially for country like Pakistan. Government also want to promote it in formal and in in-formal sector (NGO’s). “Micro finance sector Development Program” (MSDP) in 2000 was a significant step for this purpose. But these programs should also be for distant and far away areas so that those people can develop their businesses at small scale like cottage industries and this will generate more income and will improve their living standards.

Remittances can play an important role in poverty reduction. They help in maintaining present consumption of poor on housing and other facilities. As remittances increase in a country it reduces poverty. If we compare change in poverty due to remittances it will be clear that from 1990-2006 poverty has decreased from 34.4 percent to 23.9 percent due to increased effect of remittances from 1955 million U.S $ to 2725 Million U.S $.

Pro-poor policies having special focus on pro-poor growth, living in extremely bad conditions are very much necessary, like “Poverty Reduction Strategy Program” (PRSP) started in 2001 having five major elements to reduce poverty are
  • Accelerating Economic Growth and maintaining Macroeconomic policy.
  • Investing in human capital.
  • Augmenting targeted intervention.
  • Expending social safety nets.
  • Improving governance.
So, strong Macro Economic policies with good governance and Human Resource development, providing more social security benefits to poor communities and increasing their participation in decision-making is very much necessary while policy making and its implementation.

Public awareness through participation of local people or community is helpful in human development. When people know that these development activities are for their help they will automatically take part in infrastructure activities like it happened in Pakistan during lining of watercourses in different areas. Extension services or agents and Farmer’s Cooperatives can play an important role. in communicating information about new technology and about new hybrid seed varieties to increase crop production that will help in reducing the effect of food inflation.

Public-private partnership involving Government of Pakistan and other funding agencies like world bank can help in eliminating poverty  like ''Poverty  Alleviation Fund project'' (PAFP) represents a good example of targeting a specific area or community for improvement of health, education situations including gender empowerment plans.
Higher education is always given more importance than basic education at primary and middle level. So these children ultimately contribute towards child labor that is also immature and unskilled even though they are contributing to house hold income but leading to long term poverty. Previous government has started different programs like ‘‘Parha Likha Punjab’’ providing free books with monthly scholar shi has convinced many parents to send their children to school.

Subsidizing daily commodities is better bur subsidies on input side for farmers are more important. Like subsidy on fertilizers and seed on electricity are important for production purposes. Subsidy for farmers in form of price support has negative effect in rising inflation. So that should be avoided. Govt. should also control the quantity of inputs available to farmers because by subsidizing most of the input hoarding may take place that already happened in Pakistan.

One can not stop the incomings of new technology but we have to train our work force according to new innovations. World Development Report 2007 shows that Pakistan is doing expenditure of just 0.7 percent of GDP on health and just 1.6 percent on education. on its human resources. While developed nations like china is doing 5.8 percent expenditures on health and 6.2 percent on education. Obsolete methods or practices of engineering and farming need to be replaced now. Will to work is also very important and money is a greatest motivator for workers having low wages. So that can increase their efficiency and willingness of doing work.

Quality of our products needs to be enhanced specially under WTO regime. The production of major crops ha a very direct impact on the manufacturing sector. In this context textiles, food, and beverages and tobacco are the main sectors of value addition. Value added products should be given due concentration to fulfill SPS requirements.  Awareness about WTO in industrialist and farmers is required because most of them do not know about these agreements. These products can earn greater foreign exchange giving benefit to producers. Pakistan also implemented Structural Adjustment Programs (SAP’s) in connection with IMF and World Bank loans that involve substantial trade liberalization.

Food grain security to avoid food inflation is necessary. In our country due to corruption and other reasons hoarding of food items to raise their prices, smuggling of wheat to other countries and then by government policies it imports at higher cost is creating problems for common people to fulfill their food requirements.

So, although we know that poverty is a major challenge in economic growth to the whole world today and especially for Pakistan and that is a hindrance in human development. But we have to focus on development of more and more human resources as human development is the no. 1 resource of a country as it is said that if you give someone a fish as a food than you are providing him food for just one day but if you tell him how to catch a fish than you are providing him food for the whole life. Capacity building or human development may be economically, socially or morally can develop an ability in persons to work with out any out side assistance